ETF vs. FOF: What’s the difference?

Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), launched in 1990, is a fantastic product that gives investors a passive, low-cost way to multiply wealth. In some ways, ETFs are tradeable mutual funds that invest in a bouquet of stocks, currencies, commodities, or even a stock market index. This blog post helps investors understand the concept of ETFs by distinguishing between ETF vs. mutual fund and how the idea applies in the crypto world.

What is an ETF (Exchange-Traded Funds)?

Traditional investments included real estate, buying and selling shares, and investing in commodities such as gold and currencies. The advent of ETFs was a godsend for investors, offering them a novel, passive approach to investing. ETFs could track the returns based on the performance of specific indices such as the S&P 500 or a particular industry. Some ETFs also track specific commodities and even government bonds.

Like mutual funds, ETFs pool significant money from several investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of underlying assets. Like shares, ETFs trade on stock exchanges throughout the day. ETFs differ from mutual funds in pricing. An investor can buy units of mutual funds, while ETFs are traded according to the underlying ETF price or on a per-share price basis. ETFs provide investors with lower expense ratios compared to mutual funds, not to mention tax efficiency and the ability to buy and sell shares in real time. Besides, ETFs can be a useful tool for investors looking to gain exposure to a particular sector or asset class without purchasing individual stocks or bonds.

What is FOF (Fund of Funds)?

As the name suggests, the Fund of Funds (FOF) is a diversified portfolio-based investment instrument that covers multiple assets such as commodities, equity, and debt. Since FOFs invest in various funds, including mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), hedge funds, private equity funds, and real estate funds, they are called multi-manager investment assets.

The FOF structure allows investors to diversify across multiple asset classes and styles through a single investment vehicle. FOFs can also provide access to specialized or hard-to-access investment strategies and professional management and monitoring of the underlying funds. No financial instrument is risk-free. With FOFs, the biggest potential disadvantage is the additional fees. Investors are essentially paying for two layers of management – one for the FOF itself, and one for the underlying funds. Additionally, FOFs can have a layer of complexity vis-a-vis returns. The performance of the underlying funds and the FOF’s investment strategy and management influence the returns.

FOFs vs. ETFs

Although ETFs and FOFs seem alike, there are crucial differences in how they operate, the added costs, and the advantages for investors. To begin with, FOFs invest in other funds, while ETFs invest in individual securities, such as stocks, bonds, or commodities. FOFs offer an additional layer of diversification because they invest in multiple underlying funds. In contrast, ETFs provide diversification by investing in a basket of securities within a particular asset class or sector.

A major difference is that FOFs are traded like mutual funds, which means they are priced and traded only once daily, after the markets close. On the other hand, ETFs can be bought and sold throughout the trading day on an exchange, like individual stocks.

As we have seen above, FOFs are more expensive because they involve two layers of fund management. But ETFs have lower fees as they mimic an index and require less active management.

Regarding taxation, ETFs are generally considered tax-efficient compared to FOFs since they have a simple structure allowing for more efficient trading. FOFs can create tax liabilities for investors when they buy or sell the underlying funds. However, FOFs can also provide a tax-efficient way to invest in certain types of funds, such as hedge funds or private equity funds, which can be difficult for individual investors to access directly.

Basic structure

Investors must evaluate several factors based on their financial goals and risk tolerance before investing in a FOF or ETF. As a basic structure, FOFs invest in other funds, while ETFs invest in individual securities. FOFs offer an additional layer of diversification, while ETFs offer diversification by investing in a basket of securities. To read the indirect options of crypto investing without buying, click here.

Selling price

FOFs are priced and traded only once daily after the markets close, similar to mutual funds. ETFs like individual stocks can be bought and sold throughout the trading day on an exchange. As a result, ETFs generally offer greater liquidity than FOFs.

Liquidity

A good investor knows the significance of when to exit the market. Since ETFs are traded similar to an individual stock or commodity, the exit can be placed anytime during the day, offering optimal liquidity. With FOFs that operate like a mutual fund, investors may have to wait for markets to close to book an exit from the market for liquidity.

Costs

FOFs can be more expensive than ETFs because investors are paying for two layers of management—one for the FOF and one for the underlying funds. ETFs generally have lower fees because they track an index and require less active management.

Taxation

ETFs are generally more tax-efficient than FOFs because they have a structure that allows for more efficient trading of securities. FOFs can create tax liabilities for investors when they buy or sell the underlying funds.

Conclusion

Overall, both FOFs and ETFs can be viable investment options depending on an investor’s goals and preferences. FOFs offer greater diversification and access to specialized investment strategies, while ETFs provide greater liquidity and lower fees. It’s essential for investors to carefully consider the costs, liquidity, and tax implications of each option before making an investment decision. Additionally, it’s important to remember that past performance does not guarantee future results, and all investments come with some level of risk.

FAQs